Fermentation · cold kitchens

Fermenting dosa batter in a cold kitchen.

In a 19 °C winter kitchen, dosa batter can sit for two days and barely move. It does not need a hot climate. It needs 26–32 °C for about 10 hours. Here are five ways to get that, with the temperature each one actually reaches.

26–32 °CTarget

79–90 °FTarget

8–14 hAt target

18 °CStalls below

The number to aim for

Batter ferments well anywhere from 26 to 32 °C (79–90 °F). Above 36 °C it turns sour before it rises. Below 18 °C it barely ferments at all.

Where the batter sits	Typical temperature	Time to double
Winter kitchen counter	17–20 °C / 63–68 °F	26 h or more, often never
Heated living room	21–23 °C / 70–73 °F	18–24 h
Oven, light on	27–32 °C / 81–90 °F	9–12 h
Oven proof setting	30–35 °C / 86–95 °F	7–9 h
Instant Pot, Yogurt "Less"	about 30–32 °C / 86–90 °F	7–9 h

The temperatures for ovens and appliances vary by model. Put a cheap probe thermometer next to the batter the first time, and write down what yours does.

Five ways to get there

Oven with the light on

The easiest, if your oven has an incandescent or halogen bulb. Put the batter in, switch on only the light, and close the door.

Reaches · 27–32 °C in most ovens after an hour
LED oven lights · produce almost no heat, so this will not work
Too warm (above 34 °C) · leave the door open 2 cm with a wooden spoon

Stick a note on the oven doorSomeone will preheat it with your batter inside. Tape a note to the handle.

Oven proof setting

Many newer ovens have a "Proof" or "Dough proving" mode meant for bread. It usually holds about 30–35 °C (86–95 °F), which is at the warm end, so check at 7 hours.

Instant Pot, Yogurt mode

Put the batter in the steel insert and use the lowest yogurt setting ("Less" on most models). Keep the insert no more than half full, since the batter doubles. Use a glass lid or a plate in place of the sealing lid.

Setting · Yogurt, Less, 8 hours
Check at · 6 hours
The "Normal" yogurt setting runs close to 40 °C, too hot for batter

Cooler with hot water

With no oven, put the batter inside a picnic cooler next to a 1-litre bottle filled with hot tap water, about 50 °C, and close the lid. The cooler holds about 28 °C for 6–8 hours. Refill the bottle once if you are going overnight.

Warm the batter as you grind it

In winter the batter itself starts cold, especially if you soaked the grain in cold water. Grind with room-temperature water instead of ice water, aiming for a finished batter of 26–28 °C. Keep it under 30 °C, so the grinder does not overheat the dal. The batter starts fermenting straight away instead of spending hours warming up.

What else changes in winter

Soak longer: 7 hours below 20 °C, instead of 5.
Salt after: in a kitchen under 22 °C, stir the salt in after fermentation, not before.
Use a smaller vessel: a half-full container holds warmth better than a large, mostly empty one.
Do not open it to check: each look lets out warm air. Check through a glass lid, or at the times above.

How do I ferment dosa batter in winter without an oven?

Put it in a closed picnic cooler next to a bottle of 50 °C water, or wrap the container in a thick towel and leave it on top of the fridge or near, not on, a radiator. Aim for 26–32 °C.

Is it safe to leave dosa batter in the oven overnight?

Yes, with only the light on and the oven off. Tape a note to the door so nobody preheats it, and check the temperature first: it should stay under 34 °C.

Can I ferment dosa batter in an Instant Pot?

Yes, on the Yogurt setting at its lowest level ("Less") for about 8 hours, with the pot at most half full and a glass lid on. Check at 6 hours.

Why does my dosa batter ferment in summer but not in winter?

Temperature. The same batter that doubles in 8 hours at 32 °C (90 °F) can take 26 hours at 20 °C (68 °F), and may not rise at all below 18 °C.

Keep going

Links to Amazon on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through one, the site may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.